What’s better than two people who look alike having fun? Two people who look alike who can sing!

Lily & Madeleine, an adorable prairie-gothic-style sister duo from Indiana, took the stage at Lincoln Hall on Saturday night. The crowd, including many family and friends, fluctuated between cheers of support and reverent silence as the duo progressed through their edgy classic-folk-rock tracks including “Blue Blades,” “Devil We Know,” “Fumes,” and “Rabbit,” which included the delightful lyric “rabbit run for it/as if your life depends on it.”

With Lily (or was it Madeleine?) on the guitar and her sister on the keyboard, and backed by Shannon Hayden on cello, the sisters told the crowd about their upcoming European tour and gave an embarrassed “MOM!” when their Mom shouted out a request for “Stuck on the Puzzle.” If you’re looking for a night of low key beauty and charm give these two ladies from Indianapolis a whirl.